Showing posts with label sonnet 2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sonnet 2. Show all posts

Saturday, September 4, 2010

all about the benjamins

JL: Could someone say a little more about what these Sonnets were exactly? Were they ever preformed in some way? Or were they just published? And if so, who was buying them? Did people read them to one another in their parlor or something?

There is lots of speculation about what exactly these sonnets were, and it’s no surprise that the conversation about publication and purpose inevitably turns to audience. “Why did Shakespeare write these sonnets?” turns to “to whom did he write them and why?” The most popular argument is that Shakespeare wrote these sonnets beginning in the summer of 1592 for the earl of Southampton, a man who refused to marry and who stood to lose a lot (money, family, honor, etc.) if he remained single. The argument goes that Southampton’s family turned to Shakespeare to slyly convince the earl to take a wife. (The story of the earl, his life growing up, his status in the community, and his refusal to marry is pretty interesting, but perhaps it’s a story for another day…) There is also evidence that Shakespeare wrote these sonnets when the playhouses had been closed down because of the plague, and he probably would have welcomed the job and the money at a time when other playwrights were struggling to find work.

So what about publication? How did the private sonnets get to print?

Here is what Greenblatt says about the publication of the sonnets: “The first edition of the entire sequence – a quarto volume bearing the title Shake-speares Sonnets – did not appear until 1609. Shakespeare’s name, appearing in very large type, clearly was expected to sell copies…At the very center of the original title page, beneath Shake-speare’s Sonnets, there are the words “Never before Imprinted.” This prominent announcement…implies that the public has long heard of the existence of these poems but has not until now been able to purchase them. For the writing of sonnets, as contemporary readers well understood, was not normally about getting them into print, where they would simply fall into the hands of anyone who had the money and the interest to buy the book. What mattered was getting the poems at the right moment into the right hands – most obviously, of course, the object of the poet’s passion, but also the intimate (and, in the case of Shakespeare and the aristocratic young man, quite distinct) social circles surrounding both the poet and his beloved.” Greenblatt also mentions that as the individual poems started to move from private audience to public circles, printers were eager to print them. In 1599, William Jaggard printed an unauthorized collection of the sonnets called The Passionate Pilgrim. By W. Shakespeare, hoping to make money off Shakespeare’s popularity. Needless to say, only five of the twenty poems in the edition were actually written by Shakespeare…

Okay, speaking of money, it was hard to ignore the monetary overtones in this sonnet. “Small worth,” “treasure,” “thriftless,” “sum my count.” It certainly gives the feeling that if the reader wasn’t convinced by the argument of having children in Sonnet 1, then they would certainly recognize the monetary value of it here in Sonnet 2. Again, if these sonnets were directed at the earl of Southampton, this could make sense since he was about to lose his fortune unless he married.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Who is fortie winters?

Randall,

My first thought on reading this sonnet was how closely related it is to the first sonnet.  One element I felt in the first sonnet, which seems more pronounced here, is the relationship between the speaker and the subject of the poem.  The "proud livery, so gaz'd on now" makes me wonder whether it's the world doing the gazing, or whether it's the speaker.  It is difficult not to read the youth's forecast--'trenches,' 'deepe sunken eyes'-- as a mirror of the speaker's own condition.  Similarly, the speaker seems to know intimately the feeling of being young, and his praise of the youth's beauty reads as a sorry memory of the speaker's own lost youth.  It is possible, too, that the youth is more than just the site of the speaker's meditation, but is the object of his affection.

Either way, the two beings each take on a duality in this reading--the soon-to-be-old youth is not very different from the once-young but aging speaker.  This makes the closing couplet especially interesting; yes, the speaker is urging the youth to procreate, but the speaker also seems to be working out a bit of private regenesis in his self-identification with the youth.  At some point, we're going to have to start looking into love, lust, and admiration, and ask what kind of ontological unity is possible through these relations.

I'm interested in this sonnet's questions about beauty too, but I'll save those thoughts until I can pull them together a bit more.  In closing, here's a little treasure from the back of Booth's edition of the sonnets--excerpts from the 1567 translation of Ovid's Metamorphosis, preceded by a note on how Shakespeare borrows Ovid's basic structure of presenting like thoughts next to each other, with gradual changes.  Everything changes, but it stays the same.
What?  seest thou not how that the yeere as representing playne
The age of man, departes itself in quarters fowre?  first bayne
And tender in the spring it is, even like a sucking babe.
Then greene, and voyd of strength, and lush, and foggye in the blade,
And cheeres the husbandman with hope.  Then all things florish gay.
The earth with flowers of sundry hew then seemeth for too play,
And vertue small or none too herbes there dooth as yit belong.
The yeere from springtyde passing foorth too sommer, wexeth strong,
Becommeth lyke a lusty youth.  For in our lyfe through out
There is no tyme more plentifull, more lusty whote and stout.
Then followeth Harvest when the heate of youth growes sumwhat cold,
Rype, meeld, disposed meane betwixt and yoongman and an old,
And sumwhat sprent with grayish heire.  Then ugly winter last
Like age steales on with trembling steppes, all bald, or overcast
With shirle thinne heare whyght as snowe. (Ovid XV 221-235)
You'll recognize some body-land imagery here, but also particular idiomatic words--lusty, sum.  Possibly another sense of weeds, too--the young man is the weed, "greene, and voyd of strength, and lush."  Fun stuff.

-Chris

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Sonnet 2

Welcome back! First, allow me to attempt to sidestep the various editors’ attempts to make our poem intelligible and present Sonnet 2 in a form as close to what Shakespeare may have written. In modern editions I have, for example, line four yields both “tottered” and “tatter’d” (yes, in the end they mean the same thing). But let’s go with the kooky spellings and archaic punctuation.

When fortie Winters shall besiege thy brow,
And digge deep trenches in thy beauties field,
Thy youthes proud livery, so gaz’d on now,
Wil be a totter'd weed, of smal worth held:
Then being askt, where all thy beautie lies,
Where all the treasure of thy lusty daies;
To say within thine owne deepe sunken eyes,
Were an all-eating shame and thriftlesse praise.
How much more praise deserv’d thy beauties use,
If thou couldst answere this faire child of mine
Shall sum my count, and make my old excuse
Prooving his beautie by succession thine.
This were to be new made when thou art ould,
And see thy blood warme when thou feel'st it could.

This may seem banal, but I’m fascinated how Shakespeare manages to get double-duty out of so many of his images. In the first quatrain, he has set up a pair of oppositions – youth and age, livery and weeds. The latter word means “clothes” (Orsino tells Viola “let me see thee in thy woman’s weeds” in Twelfth Night), but it also reconnects us to “beauties field” (flowers?) from line 2, bridging the two images. Very cool.

What do you think of the other oppositions that emerge – shame and praise, thriftlessness and profit (“the treasure of thy lusty daies”), warmth and cold – and what can we say about Shakespeare’s use of the technique as an argumentative mode?

One more image to consider: beauty. Shakespeare uses the word four times. Is that all that’s being preserved here?

Is it too early to consider the poem’s place in the (admittedly artificial) sequence? Chris mentioned “economic transactions” in Sonnet 1. I might shift that category to “middle-class-ness” and ask if all the “treasure” and “thriftlesse” talk and the summing of accounts don’t betray the roots of a man raised in merchant weeds. Amber? What would Greenblatt say? And where does the concept of “succession” fit in?

Finally, this poem clearly iterates the theme of Sonnet 1 – the perpetuation of self through offspring. How does Sonnet 2 differ from Sonnet 1? And if you were the object of both poems’ admonishments, which would convince you more?

Randall