Monday, September 20, 2010
Where There's a Will
I'll pick up the challenge on the last two lines: "Thy unused beauty must be tombed with thee,/ Which used lives th' executor to be." I read them as Shakespeare setting up a simple reversal turning around the "unused/used" pair. If you fail to marry and have children, thus passing on your beauty, it dies with you. On the other hand, if you use your beauty appropriately -- propagation -- it continues ("lives") on.
You raise the question about "executor," which I think is exactly right. For me it really captures the merchant-class values of the sonnet and persistent imagery of money-lending and miserliness. In this sense, beauty here is capital, not to be wasted on the self, but invested in the future, and capital which if properly invested will distribute itself to one's descendants after death. I find this quantification of beauty a little distasteful. Having had Keats' "Beauty is truth, truth beauty -- that is all/ Ye know on earth and all ye need to know" drummed into me at a relatively early age, the idea that beauty ain't truth but a sort of stock portfolio to be distributed to one's children so they can be more likely to pass on the "investment" seems more than a bit boorish.
And having had such a blasphemous thought -- is Shakespeare a boor? -- like someone made aware of a cheating spouse, I start to find evidence everywhere. Go back to Sonnet 2 for a second, where our poet scolds his target: "If thou couldst answer, 'This fair child of mine/ Shall sum my count, and make my old excuse,'/ Proving his beauty by succession thine." And there it is again: Beauty passed on to one's children settles all outstanding accounts. No doubt fading beauty creates a kind of debt; do we owe the world a replenishing of its coffers of comeliness? In Sonnet 1, Shakespeare speaks of "the world's due."
Or take Twelfth Night, where Viola (as Cesario) tweaks Olivia, echoing much of what we've discussed in these first few sonnets:
VIOLA
Lady, you are the cruel'st she alive
If you will lead these graces to the grave,
And leave the world no copy.
OLIVIA
O, sir, I will not be so hard-hearted. I will give out divers schedules of my beauty. It shall be inventoried, and every particle and utensil labeled to my will: as, item, two lips, indifferent red; item, two gray eyes, with lids to them; item, one neck, one chin, and so forth" (1.5.239-249).
Again: Beauty as estate, to be divvied up amongst the progeny. When reading Twelfth Night, I have, to this point, felt that Olivia's arrogance is being mocked. In the context of the play, her regression from society to mourn her dead brother is over the top, and Viola's voice of sensibility reminds us that a woman should know "well what love women to men may owe," something Olivia seems to have forgotten. Viola also reflects here the role we see the poet of the sonnets take.
But in light of Sonnet 4, my appreciation of Olivia's response has shifted. It strikes me that our young man has had no voice in the sonnets, except that provided by his accuser (see quote from Sonnet 2 above). Olivia gives him a voice, and in doing so she seems to turn from mockee to mocker. What would she say if Viola's words were "Thy unused beauty must be tombed with thee,/ Which used, lives th' executor to be"? Maybe this:
"Send for a lawyer to draw up my will
My beauty will act as executor,
Distributing my fair in codicil:
Item, two lips, indifferent red..."
Now that's putting the "cute" in executor. I wonder what to make of the money images we've found so far. Spending and owing. Accounts and executors. Largess and niggardliness. Audit and bequest. Can Shakespeare really see beauty as so much filthy lucre?
-rrf
Saturday, September 18, 2010
Use
Thursday, September 16, 2010
Trafficking alone
One of the first things I noticed when I read this sonnet was the frequency of thou, thy, and thee. In these fourteen lines, thou is used five times, thy six, and thee twice. The effect? As Jacob suggests, we get the beginning notes of a power struggle, a manipulative mocking of sorts.
I kept returning to the lines “For having traffic with thy self alone / Thou of thy self thy sweet self dost deceive.” There is the obvious appeal to these lines in the alliteration, but then there is the curious “thy self” construction that appears three times. The first two times it appears the words are side by side. The third time it is separated by the word “sweet,” and it screams, “I am mocking you, fool!” So is this “trafficking alone” self-deception because the narrator thinks that the man is actually not all he thinks he is? He mocks his beauty, his power, and his importance. Perhaps the narrator hopes this is enough to turn him around and get him to have children.
In the spirit of primary week, I want to offer another reading of “trafficking alone” brought to you by Stephen Booth. He suggests that “having traffic with thyself alone” is not just staying single and childless, but it also suggests masturbation. Maybe Christine O'Donnell should have cited this poem in her crusade against masturbation: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzHcqcXo_NA
Lastly, since this poem (and the previous poems) seem to be about persuasion, manipulation, and self-love, I couldn't resist adding this link. It's painful and only partially related to what we've been talking about (okay, even "partially" is a stretch), but you've got to see this if you haven't: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMgyi57s-A4